Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
Moderator: Moderators
Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
Derek
Foam Board Scratch Build Plane Fanatic
HK Assault 700 (to be built)
Align Trex 600 Pro DFC, Ikon
Align Trex 500e
ZMR 250 FPV Race Quad
HK Skyfun with 5.8ghz FPV
Spektrum DX8
Citizen # 00744
Foam Board Scratch Build Plane Fanatic
HK Assault 700 (to be built)
Align Trex 600 Pro DFC, Ikon
Align Trex 500e
ZMR 250 FPV Race Quad
HK Skyfun with 5.8ghz FPV
Spektrum DX8
Citizen # 00744
Re: Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
Humm
Team Synergy / Rail Blades / Pro Tune
Pulse Battery
Castle Creations
Morgan Fuel
Pulse Battery
Castle Creations
Morgan Fuel
Re: Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
Hmm indeed. 
I'm not a fan of the melodramatic delivery. Invoking claims of any sort of tyranny with the tyrants themselves rarely works very well as a means of argument. But he has a very good point on the excessive fines and penalties aspect things. Maybe those sorts of fines and penalties make sense when it involves full scale aircraft carrying actual people, flying over personal property as a matter of course. But when as applied to small models and "drones" which are almost always flown either over empty spaces with little to no risk of personal injury or property damage, or over personal property with permission from the property owner, it makes practically no sense at all.
And being lost in all this is the insane set of requirements being heaped on "commercial" sUAS operators. Maybe in some contexts all the regs make some sense, but I think they are far and few between, while the requirements are massive overkill for 95% of use cases. Flight plans, flight logs, equipment inspections and maintenance logs (scheduled replacement regimes? redundancies?), full scale ground school, etc. A separate commercial use registration regime requiring waivers, maybe bonding?, and whatnot. Like I said, maybe in some very limited cases all of that makes sense, but in the vast majority it is simply insane and being used as a effective clamp on most all use cases, which would be considered "light" commercial/industrial, at worst.

I'm not a fan of the melodramatic delivery. Invoking claims of any sort of tyranny with the tyrants themselves rarely works very well as a means of argument. But he has a very good point on the excessive fines and penalties aspect things. Maybe those sorts of fines and penalties make sense when it involves full scale aircraft carrying actual people, flying over personal property as a matter of course. But when as applied to small models and "drones" which are almost always flown either over empty spaces with little to no risk of personal injury or property damage, or over personal property with permission from the property owner, it makes practically no sense at all.
And being lost in all this is the insane set of requirements being heaped on "commercial" sUAS operators. Maybe in some contexts all the regs make some sense, but I think they are far and few between, while the requirements are massive overkill for 95% of use cases. Flight plans, flight logs, equipment inspections and maintenance logs (scheduled replacement regimes? redundancies?), full scale ground school, etc. A separate commercial use registration regime requiring waivers, maybe bonding?, and whatnot. Like I said, maybe in some very limited cases all of that makes sense, but in the vast majority it is simply insane and being used as a effective clamp on most all use cases, which would be considered "light" commercial/industrial, at worst.
Paul Volcko
RC-Hangout's Google+ | Paul's Google+
Citizen #72 - Bending and breaking helis since Jan 2013
Goblin 500, 700 - TRex 700 - Blade 550X, 300CFX - Spektrum DX9
RC-Hangout's Google+ | Paul's Google+
Citizen #72 - Bending and breaking helis since Jan 2013
Goblin 500, 700 - TRex 700 - Blade 550X, 300CFX - Spektrum DX9
Re: Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
I'm still just... Lost, confused, don't get it, why, pissed, this apply to me, huh, really, ..... I can see it in a case of serious threat maybe.. But I'm an AMA member.. Keep the insurance.. Don't do crazy stuff that endangers others.. Nor have I see this happen.. So I don't know.. I was gonna register.. Now I think I'm just gonna fly.. Hell with it!
Team Synergy / Rail Blades / Pro Tune
Pulse Battery
Castle Creations
Morgan Fuel
Pulse Battery
Castle Creations
Morgan Fuel
Re: Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
Well.. I don't think the AMA is gonna budge the FAA..even commercially operated "drones", operated correctly within the law are giving the FAA all the fuel they need to feed this fire.
http://youtu.be/wPd7H0912Us
Since this iv heard that the compitition will no longer allow for filming via "drones"... Who knows.. Lol, on the lighter side of this skiing incident... This thing went in hard! Lol
http://youtu.be/wPd7H0912Us
Since this iv heard that the compitition will no longer allow for filming via "drones"... Who knows.. Lol, on the lighter side of this skiing incident... This thing went in hard! Lol
Team Synergy / Rail Blades / Pro Tune
Pulse Battery
Castle Creations
Morgan Fuel
Pulse Battery
Castle Creations
Morgan Fuel
- Graham Lawrie
- Moderator
- Posts: 5049
- Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2014 7:14 pm
- Location: Kinlochleven, Scotland
- Contact:
Re: Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
Oh dear:( Like how the female presenter said he did not flinch!! my money is on he never even seen it. So sad for you guys in USA, these incidents are going to damage our hobby:(
Align 600
Align 550
Align 450 Pro V2 AR7200BX
Align150
Mini-Quad 250/Emax NightHawk /Fossil V2/TBS Disco/Volt
DX6i
MHS Brain/Spartan Vortex/AR7200BX /Microbeast Plus HD
Blade mqx
Scorpion BUG
Fatshark Predator V2 & Mobius
CITIZEN # 521
Align 550
Align 450 Pro V2 AR7200BX
Align150
Mini-Quad 250/Emax NightHawk /Fossil V2/TBS Disco/Volt
DX6i
MHS Brain/Spartan Vortex/AR7200BX /Microbeast Plus HD
Blade mqx
Scorpion BUG
Fatshark Predator V2 & Mobius
CITIZEN # 521
Re: Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
No kidding. No way he was even aware of that during his run.
Paul Volcko
RC-Hangout's Google+ | Paul's Google+
Citizen #72 - Bending and breaking helis since Jan 2013
Goblin 500, 700 - TRex 700 - Blade 550X, 300CFX - Spektrum DX9
RC-Hangout's Google+ | Paul's Google+
Citizen #72 - Bending and breaking helis since Jan 2013
Goblin 500, 700 - TRex 700 - Blade 550X, 300CFX - Spektrum DX9
Re: Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
It is definitely a sad time for us, Graham. I think that you and the Mrs better start making some room because it's almost time for us to move to Scotland, lolGraham Lawrie wrote:Oh dear:( Like how the female presenter said he did not flinch!! my money is on he never even seen it. So sad for you guys in USA, these incidents are going to damage our hobby:(
Derek
Foam Board Scratch Build Plane Fanatic
HK Assault 700 (to be built)
Align Trex 600 Pro DFC, Ikon
Align Trex 500e
ZMR 250 FPV Race Quad
HK Skyfun with 5.8ghz FPV
Spektrum DX8
Citizen # 00744
Foam Board Scratch Build Plane Fanatic
HK Assault 700 (to be built)
Align Trex 600 Pro DFC, Ikon
Align Trex 500e
ZMR 250 FPV Race Quad
HK Skyfun with 5.8ghz FPV
Spektrum DX8
Citizen # 00744
- Graham Lawrie
- Moderator
- Posts: 5049
- Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2014 7:14 pm
- Location: Kinlochleven, Scotland
- Contact:
Re: Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
As long as you bring the good weather Derek:)
Align 600
Align 550
Align 450 Pro V2 AR7200BX
Align150
Mini-Quad 250/Emax NightHawk /Fossil V2/TBS Disco/Volt
DX6i
MHS Brain/Spartan Vortex/AR7200BX /Microbeast Plus HD
Blade mqx
Scorpion BUG
Fatshark Predator V2 & Mobius
CITIZEN # 521
Align 550
Align 450 Pro V2 AR7200BX
Align150
Mini-Quad 250/Emax NightHawk /Fossil V2/TBS Disco/Volt
DX6i
MHS Brain/Spartan Vortex/AR7200BX /Microbeast Plus HD
Blade mqx
Scorpion BUG
Fatshark Predator V2 & Mobius
CITIZEN # 521
Re: Alex Greve addresses the FAA's Registration
ha ha ha...there's no good weather here, Graham!!!Graham Lawrie wrote:As long as you bring the good weather Derek:)
Derek
Foam Board Scratch Build Plane Fanatic
HK Assault 700 (to be built)
Align Trex 600 Pro DFC, Ikon
Align Trex 500e
ZMR 250 FPV Race Quad
HK Skyfun with 5.8ghz FPV
Spektrum DX8
Citizen # 00744
Foam Board Scratch Build Plane Fanatic
HK Assault 700 (to be built)
Align Trex 600 Pro DFC, Ikon
Align Trex 500e
ZMR 250 FPV Race Quad
HK Skyfun with 5.8ghz FPV
Spektrum DX8
Citizen # 00744